Manarin Investment Counsel, Ltd.

Government action saved us from the recession, right? Not so fast

Click Here

---

In university classrooms—and especially the Obama White House—fancy theories of macroeconomics defy basic common sense.

Click Here

---

Brian S. Wesbury - Chief Economist
Robert Stein, CFA - Senior Economist
Date: 8/22/2011

Some are drawing parallels between today’s European debt problems and the sub-prime problems of 2008. We don’t think European debt problems will cause a recession in the US. However, there are clearly similarities between the two events.

Those similarities result from the role of government. Both the 2008 panic and today’s European debt crisis result from policy mistakes. In the US politicians of all stripes decided that using subsidies and regulations to boost homeownership was a legitimate goal. All of these policies came together in a perfect storm of over-investment in the early 2000s.

 In Europe, politicians decided that the “good life” was an achievable and legitimate goal of government: a 32-hour workweek in pleasing, stress-free jobs, with early retirement, free healthcare, and long vacations.

 The US built houses it didn’t need. Europe tried to buy a way of life it couldn’t afford. It now has 40%, or so, top income tax rates, 20%, or so, value-added tax rates and deficits as far as the eye can see. They just can’t squeeze the turnip any more. The markets won’t let them.

 This is happening despite giving banks preferential treatment when they buy government debt, allowing them to hold no capital to back up these securities. These manipulations have allowed government debt levels to rise to unsustainable levels.

 But the 2008 crisis and today’s problems are not the same. European banks bought lots of US subprime debt and the US instituted, and foolishly enforced, mark-to-market accounting. This turned what would have been a contained financial fire into an out-of-control inferno.

 Banks in the US do not have the same exposure to European debt. The five largest banks in the US have roughly $54 billion of net exposure to government, business and individual debt in the PIIGS countries. These same five institutions have $713 billion in capital.

 In the early 1980s, when Latin and South American countries were defaulting, and their debt was trading at 10 cents on the dollar, the eight largest US banks had exposure to those countries equal to 263% of capital. If, the US would have enforced mark-to-market accounting on these institutions, they all would have been bankrupt. But, it didn’t and the US went on to boom in the 1980s.

 The good news today is that the overly strict mark-to-market accounting rules of 2008 have been corrected and the debt problems of Europe are not threatening the US like the problems of the early 1980s. Moreover, in the end, Europe will find a solution that avoids wholesale default.

 Nonetheless, many investors are spooked by the threat from Europe and some recent weakness in regional manufacturing surveys. The Philadelphia Fed index, which measures manufacturing in that area, plummeted to -30.7 in August from +3.2 in July. The Empire State index, which is conducted in New York, fell to -7.7 in August from -3.8 in July.

 But we think these surveys should be discounted. Sometimes, surveys are better at picking up sentiment than real economic activity. Yes, they are hard numbers, but the numbers reflect answers to questions, not hard transactions.

 In addition, high frequency data is holding up much better. August vehicle sales are on par with July. Jobless claims, with data through 10 days ago, are hovering at the lowest levels since early Spring. Chain store retail sales, reported up through 8/16, are solidly above year-ago levels. Just this morning, it’s been reported that Delta will be buying 100 jets from Boeing. That’s on top of the 460 planes American Air ordered a month ago. Rail traffic and steel production are both showing growth as are box office receipts from theater-goers.

 It’s not 2008. European debt problems are smaller for banks in the US and, so far, high frequency data suggests consumers and businesses have not panicked.

---

This information contains forward-looking statements about various economic trends and strategies. You are cautioned that such forward-looking statements are subject to significant business, economic and competitive uncertainties and actual results could be materially different. There are no guarantees associated with any forecast and the opinions stated here are subject to change at any time and are the opinion of the individual strategist. Data comes from the following sources: Census Bureau, Bureau of Labor Statistics, Bureau of Economic Analysis, the Federal Reserve Board, and Haver Analytics. Data is taken from sources generally believed to be reliable but no guarantee is given to its accuracy.

---

As Dad to a now 4 year old Oliver and 1 year old Elise, I think about how I will instill the value of a dollar to my kids as my parents successfully did for me.  So, I’m always on the lookout for tools and ways to help.  I wanted to share this article with you http://yourfamilyfinances.com/2011/08/03/teaching-children-the-importance-of-money/ so that you can use these techniques and lessons with your kids or grandkids.  I also picked this book http://www.amazon.com/Rock-Brock-Savings-Shock-Sheila/dp/080757094X up at the Kansas City Federal Reserve Bank when I was there for a conference on Recognizing Risk in Global Agriculture.  I have read it to Oliver several times and he seems to enjoy it and is starting to learn wants vs. needs.  It is never too early to start teaching the ideas and principles of building and maintaining wealth, it certainly can help preserve a legacy that you have worked and saved and invested for during your lifetime.

---

The Wall Street Journal has a good piece running right now showing how abandoning the gold standard has destroyed our purchasing power over time.

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424053111904007304576494073418802358.html

Also

http://news.yahoo.com/nixons-colossal-monetary-error-verdict-40-years-later-140035743.html

---

If you’re not listening to our radio show, you’re missing out on important news and commentary that will help put everything into perspective and keep you on the long-term path to wealth. We love getting feedback on the show. This last week, I mentioned how President Coolidge cut taxes, and how that, in part, led to the boom of the “Roaring ‘20s.” One of our valued clients, Travis, wrote in a correction that it was actually Warren G Harding that initially cut the taxes and that Coolidge continued cutting taxes throughout his administration. He was even nice enough to back up his claim with evidence, which is always useful. Good ear, Travis, and thanks for listening!

http://www.cato.org/pub_display.php?pub_id=13561

---

The Americans for Tax Reform Foundation author an annual Cost of Government Day report. This year, according to their research, Americans will work 224 days to support the current levels of government spending and regulation.  This leaves Americans with only 4 ½ months to pay their bills and save for retirement.  Read More.

---

This video titled “Doorbell,” submitted by Don Brookins, wasn’t a prize winner in the Power Line Prize competition, but it meets the purpose of the competition very well: in simple fashion, it brings home the significance of the federal debt crisis and the impact of the debt on the next generation. It would make a terrific 60-second television commercial:

http://www.powerlineblog.com/archives/2011/07/doorbell.php

---

There’s been a lot of talk the last couple days about recessions and panic on Wall St. It’s important to remember to think in the long term during these times. This isn’t the end of the world, folks. I went on KETV and WOWT on Monday to help keep things in perspective. You can see the clips here and here.

The full stories are here and here.

---

I’ve been teaching a similar story for 35 years. Interesting...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Uyif8Z7x2Q

---